Top 10 Fan Favorite NHL Jerseys in 2025 in the US & Canada
Share
Introduction
Every season, fans show their loyalty (and style) by buying their favorite playersâ jerseys. In 2025, with breakout stars, veteran legends, and some team comebacks, certain NHL jerseys have become clear fan favorites in both the U.S. and Canada. Whether you're shopping for yourself or looking for gift ideas, knowing the top 10 gives you insight into whatâs hotâand which jerseys might hold value or trendiness.
Below we uncover the top 10 fan favorite NHL jerseys of 2025, insights into why theyâre popular, and what makes them a must-have for fans.
Top 10 Fan Favorite NHL Jerseys of 2025
These are our own picks, based on fan popularity.
| Rank | Player | Team | Why Fans Love It |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Connor McDavid (Edmonton Oilers) | Oilers | McDavid remains one of the biggest names in the NHL. Consistently leading in scoring, big social media presence, and his team performing well. |
| 2 | Auston Matthews (Toronto Maple Leafs) | Maple Leafs | With Matthewsâ goal-scoring records growing, and Toronto being one of the largest fan bases in Canada, his jersey is always a fan favorite. |
| 3 | Nathan MacKinnon (Colorado Avalanche) | Avalanche | The Avalanche are often in deep playoff runs, and MacKinnon is a star whose jerseys are popular among casual and hardcore fans. |
| 4 | Cale Makar (Colorado Avalanche) | Avalanche | As one of the top defencemen in the league, with recent awards and standout moments, his name is climbing in popularity. |
| 5 | Auston Matthews alternative / vice or âReverse Retroâ version | Maple Leafs | Alternate designs (Retro / Reverse Retro) often spark extra excitement among fans. Leafsâ alternate/retro styles are especially popular. |
| 6 | Leon Draisaitl (Edmonton Oilers) | Oilers | Strong performance, high scoring, and pairing with McDavid tends to pull attention. |
| 7 | Connor Hellebuyck (Winnipeg Jets) | Jets | Goalies arenât always top fan picks, but Hellebuyck is an exception due to fan attachment and strong visibility in Winnipeg. |
| 8 | Jack Hughes (New Jersey Devils) | Devils | Young, dynamic, rising in profile; Devils fans and neutral fans picking him up. |
| 9 | Sidney Crosby (Pittsburgh Penguins) | Penguins | A veteran legend. Fans who follow the league over decades still gravitate to him. |
| 10 | David Pastrnak (Boston Bruins) | Bruins | Strong fan base in New England, eye-catching style, consistent offensive output. |
Trends & Insights
-
Alternate/Retro Jerseys Win Fans Over: When teams release throwbacks or alternate colourways (Reverse Retro etc.), fans often buy them in addition to the regular home/away versions.
-
Playoff Success = Fan Buzz: Teams making deep playoff runs (e.g. Colorado Avalanche, Edmonton Oilers) see a surge in fan interest, especially in star playersâ jerseys.
-
Younger Stars Rising: Players like Jack Hughes, Cale Makar are more present among fan favorites, reflecting younger fan bases and interest in emerging stars.
-
Legendary Names Still Matter: Crosby, Matthews, McDavid â even with rising young stars, legendary and established names remain fan favorites because of loyal long-term fans.
What This Means for You (as a Buyer or Collector)
-
Buying a jersey of a star in a team likely to make playoffs is a safer trend investment.
-
Alternate/retro jerseys may hold collector appeal.
-
Check product details such as fabric, stitching and sizing before you buy, so you know exactly what youâre getting.
-
Keep an eye on special releases (e.g. Stadium Series, Winter Classic) for limited editions.
Sports Jersey Direct is not affiliated with, endorsed by or sponsored by any league, team or player.